Phase 4: PNAS research-article draft (main.md + composed figures + SI skeleton)

paper/pnas/main.md — the manuscript restructured as a research article
(~5.6k words main text): significance statement, abstract, introduction
(diagnosis conceded; the management thesis; the interpretation/
explanation/prediction ladder with the prediction rung stated as a
bounded controlled test), the minimal model with its exactness boundary
(learning kernel cited against ourselves), Table 1 dictionary with
per-row support levels, a five-step results ladder (grounding floor;
conservation law + operator boundaries + Fisher-Muller + directed sex +
mating structure; the jointly-necessary society; speciation across three
tiers with the emergent null; the controlled predictive test at
second-review calibration), discussion (design rules, borrowed-vs-ours
ledger, limits with the reviewer's generalisation-before-scale ordering,
what biology gets back), brief methods, 30 references.

build.py composes 6 figures by stacking committed vector PDFs (bespoke
unified re-plots deferred to submission polish); builds clean under
tectonic (15 pp incl. 6 full-page figures). si.md: SI skeleton
(propositions, claims ledger, per-tier methods, statistics, figure
list). Manifesto sections of v6 (institutions, timescales, re-minting)
compressed into Discussion per the plan; v6 remains the long-form
perspective document.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BkRLcc18rwT2Lysu6PbG7v
This commit is contained in:
Giorgio Gilestro 2026-09-06 18:24:58 +01:00
parent a40ace1821
commit bf4b1c077c
21 changed files with 928 additions and 4 deletions

View file

@ -154,8 +154,11 @@ re-run md2tex + tectonic at that point)
## Phase 4 — The PNAS manuscript — Weeks 34
- [ ] **Restructure** `paper/the-evolution-of-sex-for-ai.md` → PNAS research article
(`paper/pnas/`): Significance (~120 w, dual-audience), Abstract (~250 w), Intro (concede the
- [x] **Restructure** → PNAS research article draft (`paper/pnas/main.md` + build.py + PDF, 2026-08-11:
significance/abstract/intro/Table-1 dictionary/results ladder incl. the predictive test at
second-review calibration/discussion with design rules + ledger + limits/methods; ~5.6k words main).
*(Remaining polish at submission: pnas.cls reflow, numeric refs, bespoke unified figures.)*
Original plan: Significance (~120 w, dual-audience), Abstract (~250 w), Intro (concede the
diagnosis; thesis: the cure is sex; where this sits), **Results ladder**:
1. Collapse is drift, grounding is immigration (E1E3: exact `H_eq`, `g*≈0.048`, tail threshold
`m·p*≳1`) — concede Riis/First-Extinction, keep the immigration delta.
@ -174,12 +177,15 @@ re-run md2tex + tectonic at that point)
- [ ] **Dual-audience devices**: Table 1 = the population-genetics ↔ machine-learning dictionary;
every term defined in one clause at first use; keep "the ML statement / the genetics statement"
paired-paragraph device, compressed.
- [ ] **Figures: consolidate ~25 per-experiment figures into 5 main multi-panel figures**
- [x] **Figures: 6 composed figures** (LaTeX-level stacking of committed vector PDFs via build.py:
collapse+grounding / recombination core / rugged landscapes / society / speciation x3 tiers / LLM
tier). *(Bespoke unified re-plots = submission polish.)* Original plan:
(1 concept/dictionary+operator schematic; 2 collapse&grounding incl. the MNIST digit-decay
montage — the one image both audiences get instantly; 3 sex: FisherMuller/outbreeding/directed +
merge-don't-average; 4 speciation across three tiers; 5 society ablation + headroom law).
Everything else → SI figures. All regenerated from committed parquet.
- [ ] **SI Appendix**: results-summary.md as the skeleton; full methods, all closed forms +
- [x] **SI Appendix skeleton** (`paper/pnas/si.md`: propositions, claims ledger, per-tier methods,
statistics, figure list). Original plan: results-summary.md as the skeleton; full methods, all closed forms +
tolerances, per-experiment configs/seeds, the E13 floor proposition, confusion matrices,
reproduce.sh instructions.
- [ ] Word budget: main text ≤ ~6,000 words; check PNAS current LaTeX template + submission